01Daniel Mthimkhulubusiness partnerunknownThe technical specifications drafted by Mthimkhulu were alleged to have been tailored to favour Vossloh Espana, the manufacturer that Mashaba's Swifambo subcontracted.
02Daniel Mthimkhulubusiness partnerunknownThe specifications drafted by Mthimkhulu were alleged to have favoured the manufacturer that Mashaba's Swifambo subcontracted (Vossloh Espana).
03Lucky MontanabeneficiaryresignedSwifambo, owned by Mashaba, was awarded the R3.5 billion PRASA locomotive contract during Montana's tenure. The Public Protector found Montana exercised undue influence over procurement.
04Daniel Mthimkhulubusiness partnerunknownThe technical specifications drafted by Mthimkhulu were alleged to have been tailored to favour Vossloh Espana, the manufacturer that Mashaba's Swifambo subcontracted.
05Daniel Mthimkhulubusiness partnerunknownThe technical specifications drafted by Mthimkhulu were alleged to have been tailored to favour Vossloh Espana, the manufacturer that Mashaba's Swifambo subcontracted.
06Lucky MontanabeneficiaryresignedSwifambo, owned by Mashaba, was awarded the R3.5 billion PRASA locomotive contract during Montana's tenure. The Public Protector found Montana exercised undue influence over procurement.
07Daniel Mthimkhulubusiness partnerunknownThe specifications drafted by Mthimkhulu were alleged to have favoured the manufacturer that Mashaba's Swifambo subcontracted (Vossloh Espana).
08Lucky MontanabeneficiaryresignedSwifambo, owned by Mashaba, was awarded the R3.5 billion PRASA locomotive contract during Montana's tenure. The Public Protector found Montana exercised undue influence over procurement.
09Lucky MontanabeneficiaryresignedSwifambo, owned by Mashaba, was awarded the R3.5 billion PRASA locomotive contract during Montana's tenure. The Public Protector found Montana exercised undue influence over procurement.
10Daniel Mthimkhulubusiness partnerunknownThe technical specifications drafted by Mthimkhulu were alleged to have been tailored to favour Vossloh Espana, the manufacturer that Mashaba's Swifambo subcontracted.
11Daniel Mthimkhulubusiness partnerunknownThe specifications drafted by Mthimkhulu were alleged to have favoured the manufacturer that Mashaba's Swifambo subcontracted (Vossloh Espana).
12Daniel Mthimkhulubusiness partnerunknownThe specifications drafted by Mthimkhulu were alleged to have favoured the manufacturer that Mashaba's Swifambo subcontracted (Vossloh Espana).
13Lucky MontanabeneficiaryresignedSwifambo, owned by Mashaba, was awarded the R3.5 billion PRASA locomotive contract during Montana's tenure. The Public Protector found Montana exercised undue influence over procurement.
14Daniel Mthimkhulubusiness partnerunknownThe specifications drafted by Mthimkhulu were alleged to have favoured the manufacturer that Mashaba's Swifambo subcontracted (Vossloh Espana).
15Daniel Mthimkhulubusiness partnerunknownThe specifications drafted by Mthimkhulu were alleged to have favoured the manufacturer that Mashaba's Swifambo subcontracted (Vossloh Espana).
16Daniel Mthimkhulubusiness partnerunknownThe technical specifications drafted by Mthimkhulu were alleged to have been tailored to favour Vossloh Espana, the manufacturer that Mashaba's Swifambo subcontracted.
17Lucky MontanabeneficiaryresignedSwifambo, owned by Mashaba, was awarded the R3.5 billion PRASA locomotive contract during Montana's tenure. The Public Protector found Montana exercised undue influence over procurement.
18Daniel Mthimkhulubusiness partnerunknownThe specifications drafted by Mthimkhulu were alleged to have favoured the manufacturer that Mashaba's Swifambo subcontracted (Vossloh Espana).
19Lucky MontanabeneficiaryresignedSwifambo, owned by Mashaba, was awarded the R3.5 billion PRASA locomotive contract during Montana's tenure. The Public Protector found Montana exercised undue influence over procurement.
20Daniel Mthimkhulubusiness partnerunknownThe technical specifications drafted by Mthimkhulu were alleged to have been tailored to favour Vossloh Espana, the manufacturer that Mashaba's Swifambo subcontracted.
21Daniel Mthimkhulubusiness partnerunknownThe technical specifications drafted by Mthimkhulu were alleged to have been tailored to favour Vossloh Espana, the manufacturer that Mashaba's Swifambo subcontracted.
22Daniel Mthimkhulubusiness partnerunknownThe technical specifications drafted by Mthimkhulu were alleged to have been tailored to favour Vossloh Espana, the manufacturer that Mashaba's Swifambo subcontracted.
23Daniel Mthimkhulubusiness partnerunknownThe technical specifications drafted by Mthimkhulu were alleged to have been tailored to favour Vossloh Espana, the manufacturer that Mashaba's Swifambo subcontracted.
24Lucky MontanabeneficiaryresignedSwifambo, owned by Mashaba, was awarded the R3.5 billion PRASA locomotive contract during Montana's tenure. The Public Protector found Montana exercised undue influence over procurement.
25Lucky MontanabeneficiaryresignedSwifambo, owned by Mashaba, was awarded the R3.5 billion PRASA locomotive contract during Montana's tenure. The Public Protector found Montana exercised undue influence over procurement.
26Daniel Mthimkhulubusiness partnerunknownThe specifications drafted by Mthimkhulu were alleged to have favoured the manufacturer that Mashaba's Swifambo subcontracted (Vossloh Espana).
27Lucky MontanabeneficiaryresignedSwifambo, owned by Mashaba, was awarded the R3.5 billion PRASA locomotive contract during Montana's tenure. The Public Protector found Montana exercised undue influence over procurement.
28Daniel Mthimkhulubusiness partnerunknownThe specifications drafted by Mthimkhulu were alleged to have favoured the manufacturer that Mashaba's Swifambo subcontracted (Vossloh Espana).
29Daniel Mthimkhulubusiness partnerunknownThe specifications drafted by Mthimkhulu were alleged to have favoured the manufacturer that Mashaba's Swifambo subcontracted (Vossloh Espana).
30Daniel Mthimkhulubusiness partnerunknownThe technical specifications drafted by Mthimkhulu were alleged to have been tailored to favour Vossloh Espana, the manufacturer that Mashaba's Swifambo subcontracted.
31Daniel Mthimkhulubusiness partnerunknownThe technical specifications drafted by Mthimkhulu were alleged to have been tailored to favour Vossloh Espana, the manufacturer that Mashaba's Swifambo subcontracted.
32Daniel Mthimkhulubusiness partnerunknownThe specifications drafted by Mthimkhulu were alleged to have favoured the manufacturer that Mashaba's Swifambo subcontracted (Vossloh Espana).
33Lucky MontanabeneficiaryresignedSwifambo, owned by Mashaba, was awarded the R3.5 billion PRASA locomotive contract during Montana's tenure. The Public Protector found Montana exercised undue influence over procurement.